True Review
Current Issue Number 73 Vol.19 No.2  November 2009
 
Home Page
 
About Us
 
History
 
Current Issue
 
Past Issue
 
Submissions
 
Contact Us
 

Nebula Awards Showcase:

NEBULA AWARDS SHOWCASE 2009, ed. by Ellen Datlow.
ROC/NAL, 2009, 438 pp., $16.00.
ISBN 978-0-451-46255-8

I think the Nebula Awards Showcase series out-classes all best-of yearly anthologies. I look forward with great anticipation to each volume, and I have read them all, reviewing most of them for True Review.

My favorites:

The Merchant and the Alchemist’s Gate” by Ted Chiang won the Nebula Award for best novelette. Fuwaad ibn Abbas, purveyor of fine fabrics in the market, is looking for a gift for a customer-merchant in the district of the metal smiths when he ventures into a shop operated by a proprietor of fantastic mechanisms. The shop is operated by a mysterious guy named Bashaarat. Bashaarat, an alchemist, has procured a device that captures young Fuwaad’s imagination when, after the alchemist thrusts his arm through a hoop, then withdraws it, the same arm comes through the other side, seemingly by itself, moments later.

Fuwaad discovers that Bashaarat has some type of time-travel device. The hoop is the Gate of Seconds. The alchemist takes the young boy to see something similar at the back of the shop – a doorway called the Gate of Years. The two sides are separated by a span of 20 years.

Needless to say, Fuwaad hears stories of those who have used the gate, and ways in which the Gate has proved profitable, treacherous, or both.

Is the past fixed? Can we only learn from time – is time a fixed path, one we cannot alter?

In “Always” by Karen Joy Fowler, the Nebula Award for best short story, cults are indeed very strange, and their denizens perhaps even more so.

In his essay, “Where the Sidewalk Ends,” Barry N. Malzberg believes, like the SF critic John Clute, that SF is a “20 th Century thing,” much like the symphony was a “19 th Century thing.” Most anthologies do not have SF in them anymore, Malzberg argues, but fantasy. There is nothing but nostalgia anymore for SF – so why not dwell on what was?

Malzberg notes this is the 43 rd annual Nebula Award anthology – has there really been that many?

Kathleen Ann Goonan provides some of her own background to the history of SF with “Why I Write Science Fiction.”

In “Pol Pot’s Beautiful Daughter” by Geoff Ryman, which was a nominee for best novelette, Sith lives in the world of her father’s regime – as well as its death and destruction. But that reality is as unknown to her as ice conditions at the South Pole. She is merely trying to have her own life, her own memories.

“Stars Seen Through Stone” by Lucius Shepard, the Nebula Award nominee for novella, brings us to the backwoods/backwater town in western Pennsylvania called Black William. The town is rife with blue collar everything, including the river Polozny, close to which boasts a recording studio, of all things, called Soul Kiss Records. Into the life of Vernon, the studio proprietor, drifts a kid by the name of Joseph Stanky of McKeesport, Pa. The artist Stanky literally does his own thing, what Vernon refers to as “postmodern deconstructed blues,” of which the recording magnate dubs as having “cult potential.”

One day some kind of divine force intrudes, partially as the result of a composition of Stanky’s labeled “Stars Seen Through Stone,” and brings out some kind of personality “enhancement” to individuals in the local populace. All of a sudden, vocalists can sing with more vibe, painters have more definition, bakers create more tasty donuts, etc. What is the magic Stanky has created? What does it all mean?

In “Clubbing,” Ellen Asher, retired editor-in-chief of the Science Fiction Book Club, writes about her 34-year career at the club and some of the changes since. She rants about corporate stupidity (a redundancy), but also points out ways in which the club helped bring SF to the masses (not such a bad thing).

“What You Saw Was What You Got” by Howard Waldrop. This is a review of the year in films, and as a critic, Waldrop is far, far too forgiving.

“Pan’s Labyrinth: Dreaming With Eyes Wide Open” by Tim Lucas is a tribute to Guillermo del Toro and his film.

The Damon Knight Grand Master Award went to Michael Moorcock, and an appreciation is written by Kim Newman with a story selected by Michael, “The Pleasure Garden of Felipe Sagittarius.”

“The New Golden Age: The Rise of Young Adult Science Fiction and Fantasy” by Gwenda Bond is included. Also, “Fountain of Age” by Nancy Kress, which won the Nebula Award for best novella, is included.

There is also a tribute to Ardath Mayhar by Joe R. Lansdale.

Andrew M. Andrews

In This Issue
10 Minutes - 10 Months - 10 Years - Suzy Welch Green You - Deirdre Imus Additional Reviews ISIS - Douglas Clegg Oscar Wilde - Gyles Brandreth Dan Brown - The Lost Symbol

Lavender Morning - Jude Deveraux Home Made Life - Molly Wizenberg He Is Legend - Christopher Conlon Nebula Awards - Ellen Datlow The Wreck of the Godspeed - James Patrick Kelly Robert Silverberg - Other Spaces, Other Times

Film Reviews

Next Time In True Review

A Sample Of Our Upcoming Reviews...

AN IRISH COUNTRY CHRISTMAS: by Patrick Taylor. Tor/Forge, 495 pp., $14.99.
ISBN 978-0-7653-2072-8

THE FANTASY WRITER’S ASSISTANT, And Other Stories, by Jeffrey Ford. Golden Gryphon, 2002, 2009, 253 pp., $14.95.
ISBN 1-930846-57-6

HOME FOR CHRISTMAS: by Andrew M. Greeley. Tor/Forge, 191 pp., $14.99.
ISBN 978-0-7653-2250-0

AMELIA EARHART: The Sky’s No Limit, by Lori Van Pelt. Tor/Forge, 240 pp., $12.99.
ISBN 978-0-7653-2483-2

DINNER AT MR. JEFFERSON’S, by Charles A. Cerami. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2008, 272 pp., $25.95.
ISBN 978-0-470-08306-2

A SIMPLE CHRISTMAS: by Mick Huckabee. Penguin/Sentinel, 176 pp., $19.95.
ISBN 978-1595230621